Fences Work

by Stephen Bennett on June 30, 2013

BorderFence2With the renewed debate of Border Security and the Border Fence regarding the current Amnesty push in Congress, it is worth revisiting an article I wrote several years ago as it is even more pertinent now than when it was written…

Fences work, they just have to be engineered and properly constructed. Consider the 14-mile double-layer fence between San Diego and Tijuana, Mexico. Its benefits in stopping illegal entry into the U.S. were immediate and long lasting. Prior to the fence, illegals poured through the border here and in one 24-hour period the border patrol reported apprehending 2,000 illegal aliens. According to a 2005 Congressional Research Service report illegal alien apprehensions along the fence region dropped from 202,000 in 1992 to 9,000 in 2004, a reduction greater than 95%. Additionally, there was a 53% drop in San Diego’s crime rate, as reported by Congressman Duncan Hunter. The open borders lobby ignores these facts when they say fences will not work.

So, fences won’t work? Let’s take an around the world tour and see if anything else with fences is going on.

North Korea/South Korea: Called “the scariest place on earth” by President Bill Clinton, this 155-mile-long, 2.5 mile wide demilitarized zone has separated the two Koreas since 1953 and is the most heavily fortified border in the world.

North Korea/China: It was confirmed in 2006 that China was in the midst of fence construction on its border with North Korea. Long amicable allies, China had become concerned with the large illegal influx of North Koreans into its territory over the previously lightly guarded border. The project is spearheaded by China’s military in order to establish security.

Belfast, Northern Ireland: Nicknamed the “Peace Line,” this series of brick, iron, and steel barriers was first erected in the 1970s to curb escalating violence between Catholic and Protestant neighborhoods. The barriers have more than doubled in number over the past decade, and currently stretch over thirteen miles of Northern Ireland.

Cyprus: A 112-mile-long construction of concrete, barbed wire, watchtowers, minefields, and ditches has separated the island’s Turks from its Greeks since 1974. The Turkish Cypriot government reduced restrictions on cross-border travel in April of 2003.

Morocco/Western Sahara: Known as “The Wall of Shame,” these ten-foot-high sand and stone barriers, some mined, run for at least 1,500 miles through the Western Sahara. Built in six stages from 1980 to 1987, they are intended to keep West Saharan guerrilla fighters out of Morocco.

Israel/Palestine: The Israeli government, observing how effective the security fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip has been at keeping out suicide bombers, decided in 2003 to start fencing off the West Bank as well because after scores of suicide bombings and daily terrorist attacks against its civilians that had killed more than 850 people and wounded thousands more since September 2000. The 490-mile anti-terrorist barrier has proven a huge success even before it was finished as statistics two years into the project indicated attacks had declined by as much as 90 percent and the number of Israelis murdered and wounded has decreased by more than 70% and 85%, respectively.
The fence should be fully completed by 2010. Note: Hamas militants in Jan. 2008 blew up a 200 meter portion of the Gaza strip fence which enabled thousands of Palestinians to pour into Egypt before order was restored.

India/Bangladesh: India started construction in 2000 of a 2500 mile fence based on the design of the Israeli West Bank barrier. Its purpose is to stop smuggling, terrorist infiltrations and illegal immigration from Bangladesh. To date, approximately 1550 miles have been built. Wikipedia reports the U.S. has pumped $1.2 billion into the project.

India/Pakistan: In 1989 India began erecting a fence to stem the flow of arms from Pakistan. So far it has installed more than 700 miles of fencing, much of which is electrified and stands in the disputed Kashmir region. The anti-terrorist barriers will eventually run the entire 1,800-mile border with Pakistan.

India/ Myanmar (Burma): A separation barrier that India started constructing in 2003 to seal off its 975-mile border with Myanmar. The stated purpose is to curtail cross border crime, smuggling, drug trafficking, insurgency and illegal immigration.

Pakistan/Afghanistan: Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, citing India’s success with its fence on the Pakistan border announced in Sept. 2005, his intention to build a 1,500 mile fence and mine the border with Afghanistan. This is thought to be more likely political posturing and without a massive influx of U.S. dollars will never come to fruition. The political and tribal hurdles would likely doom any serious intention.

Kuwait/Iraq: The 120-mile demilitarized zone along this border has been manned by UN soldiers and observers since the Gulf War ended, in 1991. Made of electric fencing and wire, and supplemented by fifteen-foot-wide trenches, the barrier extends from Saudi Arabia to the Persian Gulf. Kuwait has since installed an additional 135-mile iron partition.

United Arab Emirates/Oman: Starting in 2005, the UAE has been erecting a barrier fence along its border with Oman to prevent the flow of drugs, terrorists and illegal immigrants.

Russia/ Chechnya: Noting Israel’s success with its West Bank barrier Russia has declared its intention to seriously consider constructing a fence on its Chechnya border in order to combat Muslim terrorism.

Uzbek/Afghanistan: A barrier coursing the entire 130 mile border consisting of two fences, one barbed wire and the second a taller 380-volt electrified fence with land mines and patrolled by armed Uzbek soldiers.

Malaysia/Thailand: In 2001, the two countries jointly agreed to construct a fence along their 400 mile border to reduce smuggling and stop the infiltration of Malaysian Muslim extremist groups that led to the South Thailand Insurgency, a separatist campaign in Thailand’s three southernmost provinces. The actual progress on this fence is unknown at this time.

Brunei/Malaysia: In 2005, Brunei built a security fence along its 20-kilometer border with Limbang, Malaysia in order to control illegal immigration and smuggling.

United States/Mexico: In the mid-1990s President Clinton initiated two programs; Operation Gatekeeper and Operation Hold the Line, to crack down on illegal immigration from Mexico. They produced a system of high-tech barriers, including a fourteen-mile fence separating San Diego from Tijuana. By 2005, security barriers stretched along at least seventy miles of the border. Recognizing the success of the San Diego corridor barrier, Congress passed the Secure Fence Act of 2006 mandating the construction of 700 miles of border fence along the Mexico border including “two layers of reinforced fencing” and listed five specific sections of border where it should be installed. Just before Christmas 2007, Congress passed an Omnibus spending bill that removed the two-tier requirement and the list of locations specified. Also, an additional kicker was slipped into the bill, the Hutchinson Amendment which allowed the secretary of DHS to not build the fence anywhere he deemed it “not appropriate”. So how this all shakes out for the border fence construction that is plodding along on our southern border and its ultimate success remains to be seen. (Update 2013: DHS has neglected its responsibility to build the fence and Congress has shirked its duty to ensure it was completed as legislated).

Botswana/Zimbabwe: The government of Botswana claims to have started building a ten-foot-high electric fence along its border with Zimbabwe to control the spread of foot-and-mouth disease. However, most Zimbabweans believe that the fence — begun in 2003 and intended to stretch up to 300 miles — really aims to stanch the immigration flow from troubled Zimbabwe into calmer Botswana.

Saudi Arabia/Yemen: In 2003 Saudi Arabia began building a ten-foot-high barrier along its border with Yemen to prevent terrorist infiltration. Heeding Yemeni protests that the fence violated a border treaty, the Saudi government vowed to complete the project in cooperation with Yemen. A February 2007 report in the Arab Times indicates the Saudi’s remain committed to fully fencing its border with Yemen.

Saudi Arabia/Iraq: In 2006, the Saudi’s put out calls for bid on a 900 kilometer fence running the distance of its border with Iraq. It is reported this is part of a larger package of fence building to secure all of Saudi Arabia’s 6,500 kilometers of border.

Ceruta/Morroco and Melilla/Morocco : A border fence built by Spain with EU funding between Morocco and the Spanish city’s of Ceruta and Melilla on the north Moroccan coast to stop illegal immigration and smuggling.

Egypt/Gaza: The United States announced in March 2008 that it is giving Egypt $23 million and technical assistance to help Egypt build a border fence along the Gaza-Egypt border to eliminate smuggling and entry of Palestinian militants. The dichotomy here is obvious as the U.S. is set to help Egypt secure its border yet sabotages and drags it feet in securing our own border with Mexico.

All of the fences detailed that have been built are successful, some to more degrees than others, but successful nonetheless. Don’t let anyone ever tell you that fences won’t work because they do. If fences didn’t work, governments all over the world would not be investing in them. Critics of the U.S. border fence like to portray it as an evil Berlin Wall type barrier, which could not be further from the truth. Our border fence does not keep people in and reduce their freedom; it keeps illegal immigrants and terrorists out thereby securing freedom and security on both sides of the border. It also separates people of two distinct nations unlike the Berlin Wall, which separated two of the same people, Germans from Germans. If there were not the propensity of Mexican nationals and OTM’s (Other Than Mexicans) to illegally cross our border at will and help themselves to whatever they found to their liking in our country while encouraged and abetted by the Mexican and other foreign governments, the border fence would be unnecessary. Since the mass illegal crossings won’t cease anytime soon, perhaps never, the fence becomes a necessity.

If you don’t wish to overload the naysayers negative mindset and illogical open borders philosophers with all the facts above, then just give them this quote from poet Robert Frost (and supported by a study co-authored in 2007 by the New England Complex Systems Institute and Brandeis University)…”Good fences make good neighbors”. Or, if you’d just like to be a bit snarky ask them this, “If fences don’t work why is there one around the White House?”

Note: information on some of the fences was gleaned from an article by Abigail Cutler that appeared in Atlantic Monthly in 2005. A number of them were gathered from personal research.

{ 2 comments }

 

NoAmnesty

  1. Illegals already costing us over $110B per yr. They will never ever pay more into economy than they remove.
  2. Welfare massive blow up, crushing national debt, $6.3T cost.
  3. Removes the current ‘public charge law’ therefore any alien can go on welfare.
  4. Increases number of guest workers by 50%, doubles number of H1B (skilled) workers.
  5. Doubles legal immigration within a decade after enactment—and triples it if you include the 12 million amnestied illegal aliens.
  6. Business gets $5K incentive per employee to hire former illegals in preference to citizens or legal immigrants.
  7. Border Security implementation is left up to the whims and discretion of DHS Secretary Napolitano.
  8. DHS Secretary Napolitano can stop deportations and waive requirements of amnesty recipients. Does not end abuse of prosecutorial discretion or administrative amnesty by the Obama administration.
  9. Doesn’t require the deportation of any illegal alien. Even if an illegal’s amnesty status were denied.
  10. Wussy factor. Prohibits ICE enforcement in “sensitive locations”.
  11. Taxpayer funded lawyers for illegals to fix any problems to get legalized.
  12. Stimulus program and job security for immigration attorneys.
  13. Stimulus program for LaRaza-MALDEF-SEIU-ACORN activist groups to guide illegals through the amnesty process.
  14. Even the 9/11 Saudi terrorists would have received amnesty regardless of visa overstay. Thank Corker-Hoeven.
  15. Criminals accepted. Obama-Napolitano will find a way to get them in.
  16. Makes a mockery of rule of law & our national sovereignty, illustrates we have no will of enforcement.
  17. Illegals legalized right away, border security maybe-someday-maybe not.
  18. Americans pushed out of jobs, those still working face reduced wages.
  19. Lip service to E-Verify employment verification. Weak on implementation to appease big business and illegal workers. Even voids state and local E-Verify laws.
  20. Encourages even more illegal immigration.
  21. Chain migration…massive chain migration.
  22. Pork – cheap fishery workers for Alaska.
  23. Pork – stimulus program for Las Vegas casinos and tourism.
  24. Pork – cheap workers for Big Biz, Agri Biz, Big Labor, Big Tech.
  25. Pork – Obama mobiles.
  26. Pork – Marco phones.
  27. Guaranteed low info liberal voting block for Democrats, permanent one party Fed Gov.
  28. National ID card, it’s coming.
  29. Big Bro creation of massive national biometric database of virtually every adult in U.S. administered by DHS.
  30. Affirmative Action for (former) illegal aliens. Stimulus program for grievance industry.
  31. More  bureaucracy, the new Office of Legal Access Programs, to provide illegal aliens with “legal orientation programs” that help fight deportation.
  32. More bureaucracy, new Bureau of Immigration and Labor Market Research via fees imposed on business.
  33. More bureaucracy, new Citizenship Foundation run by community organizers to prepare illegals for citizenship.
  34. More bureaucracy, expansion of Fed Depts to process 11-12-15-20-30 M who knows how many illegals?
  35. Expands the troubled/abused Asylum Refugee System. More Boston Bombers, Somalis, Islamists/Sharia…
  36. Fraud. Massive fraud in 1986 amnesty process, expect even more with this one. Manufactured claims.
  37. It’s Obama-Schumer-Durbin-Mendenez-Bennet-Rubio-McCain-Graham-Flake’s idea.
  38. Supported by Big Gov-Big Biz-Big Labor-Big Religion-Big Globalists-Soros-Reid-Pelosi-Rove-Jeb/GW Bush-Norquist…
  39. Creates national pandering contest between the Evil Party and the Stupid Party. Who can out pander who?
  40. Will never have to leave home to visit the Third World. Priceless? Nope!
  41. Gives Obama the final piece he needs to Fundamentally Transform America.

 

{ 0 comments }

Twenty Six Years Ago Today…

June 12, 2013

Today marks President Reagan’s historic speech at the Brandenberg Gate where he told the Soviet Union’s General Secretary of the Communist Party “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall”. And down it came with the demise of the Soviet Union’s empire. Reagan’s quote says it all: “Here’s my strategy on the Cold War: We win, they [...]

Read the full article →

Democrat NC Senator Compares GOP Policies with Boston Bombing

April 27, 2013

Submitted without further comment, NC Senator Angela Bryant compares the Republican agenda to the Boston Bombing:   Bryant has since deleted the tweet above and issued a typical, political non-apology. To be clear, no comparison between Boston tragedy and NCGA; #ncga #NCGOP @nashncgop #NCPOL #ncgov @newsobserver — Angela R. Bryant (@angelareb) April 25, 2013 However [...]

Read the full article →

NC House Bill 101 Aims to End the Death Tax

March 31, 2013

Death shouldn’t be a taxable event. At least, that’s the consensus of the 23 Republican House members who have signed on as co-sponsors to House Bill 101 which would repeal North Carolina’s “death tax.” The companion bill in the Senate boasts 29 co-sponsors, a majority of the Senate. Americans for Prosperity is actively supporting the [...]

Read the full article →

GOP Commits Suicide; Endorses Reconquista

March 25, 2013

GOP Commits Suicide; Endorses Reconquista – Stephen Bennett The coffin is prepared. All that’s left is to drive in the nails. Their game of Russian roulette is now being played fully loaded. The death panel is assembled. We’ve known Democrats generally distain the Constitution. We now know that the Republican Party, who professes to be [...]

Read the full article →

NC Rep. Holding Issues Statement On White House Tours

March 7, 2013

The Obama administration marches on, pushing more sequester fear mongering, state representatives and senators have issued statements to their voters. Today Congressman George Holding sent the following letter to his constituents following the Obama administration’s announcement this week regarding White House tours:   Dear Friend, The White House announced earlier this week that White House [...]

Read the full article →

Senate to Vote Wednesday on Charlotte Airport Takeover

March 2, 2013
Thumbnail image for Senate to Vote Wednesday on Charlotte Airport Takeover

The NC Senate will vote Wednesday on a controversial bill that would strip Charlotte of control over its airport.  The bill, sponsored by Republican Senators Bob Rucho, Tom Apodaca, and David Curtis, would create a new bureaucracy called the Charlotte Regional Airport Authority which would seize control of the facility from the city. A companion bill in [...]

Read the full article →

Kay Hagan Tweets Support for Keystone XL Pipeline

February 26, 2013

I joined my colleagues in a writing bipartisan letter to Sec Kerry today urging swift approval of #Keystone pipeline 1.usa.gov/13R5vQI — Senator Kay Hagan (@SenatorHagan) February 26, 2013 The #Keystone XL pipeline will supply energy from our closest friend & partner, and it will create jobs in the US — Senator Kay Hagan (@SenatorHagan) February [...]

Read the full article →

#Senate2014: Kay Hagan Gets A Challenger In NC

February 20, 2013

Dr. Greg Brannon of Cary, NC has officially thrown his hat in the ring.  His candidacy was mentioned in my Senate 2014 sticky post earlier this week, but today I received a press release (below). The Daily Haymaker reported at the end of January: The Republican Liberty Caucus and The Eastern North Carolina Tea Party have united behind a Wake County [...]

Read the full article →